Bankruptcy and Foreclosures in Wisconsin
Posted on Feb 27, 2013 in Bankruptcy, Chapter 13, Foreclosure - Saving Your Home, Mortgage Foreclosure Defense, Wisconsin
“After losing the standing argument in state court, it is beyond frivolous for the Debtors to file bankruptcy, reiterate the same losing arguments and now claim, not only that the Note is invalid, but that the foreclosing creditor and its attorneys are liable for RICO violations for filing the Note as an exhibit to the foreclosure complaint.”
– Rinaldi, et al. v. HSBC Bank USA, N.A., as Trustee, et al. (12-2412, Feb. 22, 2013, Hon. Susan V. Kelley)
As the Eastern District of Wisconsin has made clear over the last year, you cannot litigate and lose a state court foreclosure case, then turn around and relitigate the case in bankruptcy court. The Rooker-Feldman doctrine (as described here in this previous blog post) prevents this second bite at the apple.
This decision was quite thorough because in addition to standard objections to the proof of claim and standing arguments, the debtors/adversary plaintiffs also alleged common law fraud, RICO violations, and other claims against the original lender, the servicer/proof of claim filer, and numerous individuals and law firms. Thus, the judge was required to analyze the merits of each before ultimately dismissing each and every claim.
The moral here: If you believe you are the victim of foreclosure fraud, please contact us immediately. If you have a judgment of foreclosure entered in state court, it is extra important that this be discussed before you decide to challenge it in bankruptcy court. Contact a Lakelaw attorney for more information.